tweets

Tuesday, November 21, 2006

The epidemic of "Therapeutic alienation" in India

Last weekend I watched a very interesting interview on PBS. John McWhorter, the author of "Winning the Race" talked about what is wrong with welfare and black empowerment. He described "the heroics of idle protest and theatrical rage" that characterize today's black leadership as "therapeutic alienation."

He says ..."therapeutic alienation: alienation unconnected to, or vastly disproportionate to, real-life stimulus, but maintained because it reinforces one's sense of psychological legitimacy, via defining oneself against an oppressor characterized as eternally depraved."

It was an ah-ha moment for me. I finally have a term for what desis from M.K. Gandhi to today's leaders indulge in. Ok, I am sure the reference to Gandhi will draw criticism from some quarters. But, think. Did Gandhi care more about winning independence or proving the British as morally inferior? And, today we have people of all kinds indulging in similar behavior (though their morals, inf any, are really low).

Now, there is a new report that was leaked in sync with the Uttar Pradesh elections that finds Indian muslims that worse off than other religious groups. It is a call for religion based reservations. This is when about 75% of indian muslims are covered by existing caste based reservations. So, on one hand we have this high sounding concepts like secularism, equality and equal opportunity while on the other hand we have government policies that promote division. How long before the shias, sunnis and other groups all ask for their own quotas?

Monday, November 20, 2006

SOA stands for "Same Old Architecture"

Last week I went for an IDC conference on "Service Oriented Architecture" (SOA). I went there hoping that the conference speakers will help provide a clearer perspective on why SOA is going to change the world.

The key note got off to a real bad start with one of the analysts presenting pretty much throwing all buzzwords, jargons and cliches in one 15min talk. There were a number of references to Geoffery Moore and his concepts to a predominantly tech audience who probably have never heard of him. It only got worse as the day progressed.

Vendors, both product and services firms, tried their best to convince everyone that their tool/ approach will offer the best. They took great pains to convince that SOA is not web services yet the only example of SOA that was demonstrated was a email validation service using web services. The services vendors talked a great deal about SOA governance but had a hard time talking about how it was different from IT Governance and where it fit in. There were a number of times when different speakers had radically different thoughts on what a term meant. A guy from the services side of a tools vendor said SOA Governance is like IT Governance but at an enterprise level while a CIO of an utility company said SOA Governance is about security and service life cycle management.

I am appalled by the number of snake oil salesmen in the IT industry. No wonder IT credibility is really low. We have a poor track record, poor communication skills but we feel the need to come up with some new term every three years and try to sell it to the world as the new silver bullet. Why can't we call it as we see it? I called SOA "old wine in a new bottle". But, a colleague of mine said it better - "old underwear in new packaging." The SOA story is just one example. The other one is SOX (Sarbanes Oxley bogey). There are a whole lot of products and vendors offering solutions for SOX compliance. SOX does not directly mention IT anywhere but that has not stopped vendors from proposing incredibly stupid solutions. I once had a consultant from a large service provider suggest that we should run SSL on our LAN for SOX compliance.

There were one or two speakers at this conference who made sense. There was this guy from HP who started off by saying "I was doing SOA twnety years back." His point was SOA is nothing but doing IT architecture right - to support the business functions. The new technologies and standards just make things easier.

Revolution in IT will happen when IT personnel and technology vendors understand the business and its problems.

Sunday, November 12, 2006

In memory of a friend who I wish I had known better

I tried emailing Prasad last week, one of my once in a year or so email ping. And, it bounced back. Hotmail informed me that the mailbox was no longer available - a sign of it not being in use for more that four months. I wondered if Prasad like a number of others had decided to use Gmail. So, I searched for other email addresses that I might have for him. When I did not find any I searched on the Web.

The first hit was an article in "The Hindu" about being the only child from early this year. He was quoted in it. But, it was the second hit that made me go cold. It was an item from "The Hindu" obituary from April 25th announcing Prasad's transition on April 20th. Prasad must have been 42 or at the most 43 years.

I still remember vividly how I met Prasad. It must have been 1993 I had responded to an advertisement in the IEEE Spectrum magazine about an organization called Global Intuition Network (GIN). They claimed to promote intuition as a management tool. I was intrigued and I wrote to them. Turns out Prasad had sent a letter,too. And, since my letter must have arrived there first they asked Prasad to get in touch with me about organizing the local charter. Prasad sent me a letter. And, I was quite surprised. Anyway, I called him on the phone to find out what his interest was. He told me that he had an engineering degree, a MBA and he ran a small robotics and automation firm. Later, during our first face to face meeting at his office I learned that his engineering degree was from IITB and the MBA was from Carnegie Mellon. I remember asking him "What are you doing here?". And, his response was, "This is my company. I would be nowhere else."

We never did anything about GIN but we kept in touch. It was mostly my initiative. But, he always made it a point to respond to the letters or make time to meet me. After I moved to the US and my folks moved out of Chennai in 1999 the once in 3 months contact reduced to one or two emails a year. My emails were always the same - "how is work? hope your mom is doing well." His dad had passed away back when he was in college. And, his responded promptly, as always. He told me about the pressure from the Chinese entry into the Indian market, the increasing wages etc...I did not have anything to offer him. As always he seemed quirky as ever, a bit defiant and making the best of the situation.

In December of 2003 I decided to fly into India via Chennai. I called Prasad when I got there. And, he invited us over to his home for breakfast. I went to his home, met his mom for the first time and had breakfast with them. He seemed upset about things at work - an old timer had swindled him and another had decided to move on. He invited us to stay on, said he would like to get to know my wife, who like him is an only child and an air force child. But, we were on the run - the typical 3 week vacation from the US. I promised to try spend time with him on my way out knowing fully well that it probably would not happen due to other commitments. Prasad dropped us off at our next appointment, a friend of mine from my undergrad days. And, during the drive managed to fool my friend into believing that he was a hired driver. It was hilarious. That was the last time I met Prasad.

In December of 2005 I did return to India on vacation. But, this time I skipped Chennai altogether. We spoke briefly over the phone. He sounded upset that I had not planned on coming to Chennai. He seemed to be holding back something. I did not ask, he did not tell. I promised to keep in touch by email or phone - my usual "ping". I don't know if I did email him after that. I want to think that I did. I never received any response. So, maybe I never did.

I wonder if things would have been different had I been in Chennai. Or, would we have remained the same. I do wish I had asked him what was on his mind, why he had not married, if could have been of any help.... I wish I had been more involved. I thank you, my friend, for the memories. I just wish there were a lot more.

Saturday, November 11, 2006

Child Rights or Relief... what is in a name?

Looks like the favorite desi pastime of re-naming cities and organizations has bitten my favourite charity. Child Relief & You (a.k.a CRY) has decided to change its name to Child Rights & You (a.k.a CRY). But,looks like laziness caught the better of them (at least the IT staff). So, while the indian site has it as Child Rights & You (http://www.cry.org/index.html),the US landing page (http://america.cry.org/index.asp) still has Child Relief & You.

BTW, I think the new name for Bangalore is quite appropriate - Bengaluru, derived from Benda Kaal Ooru - that's "boiled beans town". Yes, you guys are full of hot air. Maybe, it is the beans ;).